Marc Entze
6-3-2004
The Clark Fork Route: Short-lived Alternative to the Mullan Road
At an average of ten million dollars per year, the Montana gold trade was very lucrative and competition for the trade developed between the principal supply centers of the northern West: San Francisco, Portland and St. Louis. Portland and St. Louis were the principal players, both established on navigable rivers on the fringes of the gold country. San Francisco was a powerful contender, but lacked direct connection to the northern mines. As a result Portland controlled navigation on the Columbia and Snake Rivers, and St. Louis dominated the Missouri River trade to Fort Benton.
Despite the Federal Government’s funding of the construction of the Mullan Road between Walla Walla and Fort Benton, alternative routes to the gold fields existed. These routes were an effort to find easier and faster travel through the interior. The most notable alternative was the Clark Fork Route. This route utilized steamboat transportation for a much greater distance than the Mullan Road, with steamboats navigating Pend Oreille Lake and the Clark Fork River to within 125 miles of Fort Benton. Although the Clark Fork Route lasted only three years, from 1866 to 1869, it illustrates the shortcomings of the Mullan Road and the demand for improved transportation networks.
The Clark Fork Route is the result of Portland business interests trying to capture the very profitable mining trade of Montana and Idaho. Historian Carlos Schwantes writes that it “cost nearly the same . . . to ship goods from Portland to Montana as it did from Saint Louis or San Francisco.” From Portland, the primary route to the mines was to navigate up the Columbia River to Wallula, where stages connected Walla Walla to the steamboat landing. In the 1860s Walla Walla was the largest and most prosperous town of the interior and the beginning of the long overland trip via the Mullan Road. Saint Louis depended on Missouri River navigation to reach the mines. Both of these routes faced severe difficulties: the Mullan Road was a difficult and non maintained passage across the Bitterroot Mountains and the rugged terrain dictated the use of pack trains. On the other hand, the Missouri River was navigable for only a few short months of the year and faced many dangers, including Indian attacks and constant threat from snags and sand bars on the river. Because of these problems, the Oregon Steam Navigation Company (OSN), organized in Portland to operate steamboats and portage railways on the Columbia River route, desired to increase steamboat navigation to cut transportation costs and attract more of the trade to Portland and away from St. Louis.
The OSN created the Oregon and Montana Transportation Company in 1865 to organize their plans for inland navigation. Almost immediately work was begun on a new steamboat, the Mary Moody, for operations on Pend Oreille Lake. The machinery from the retired Colonel Wright, the vessel which pioneered navigation on the Columbia, Snake and Clearwater Rivers, was freighted overland to Pend Oreille Lake. Lumber for the new boat was sawed from timber on location. Just four months after construction began, the Mary Moody was completed and plying the waters of the lake. Two additional steamboats, the Cabinet and Missoula, were constructed for service on the Clark Fork River. Now supplies from Portland could by pass Walla Walla and the Mullan Road in favor of the White Bluffs landing, 50 miles north of Wallula on the Columbia River. The OSN believed that they could capture much of the Montana trade from St. Louis because of the many dangers and short navigable season on the Missouri River.
With the steamboats in service, the OSN had a “chain” of navigation reaching from Portland far into Montana. Steamboats from Portland landed at White Bluffs, the supplies were freighted overland to the southern shore of Pend Oreille Lake, and put aboard the Mary Moody. The Mary Moody then navigated the 85 miles across the lake to the Cabinet Rapids, where the cargo was unloaded for a short portage and loaded on the Cabinet. From the Cabinet Rapids, the Clark Fork was navigable to Thompson Falls, where another portage was undertaken to the Missoula, which steamed up the Clark Fork River as far as the mouth of the Jocko River, 125 miles from Fort Benton. Business on the Clark Fork Route was brisk. On her first trip, the Mary Moody loaded 85 pack animals, five tons of freight and fifty passengers. The Montana Post praised the new steamboat service, noting that “a continuous line of water travel, nearly two-hundred miles in length, and avoiding the very worse and only bad portions of the [Mullan Road] . . . will thus be offered.”
Despite the initial success of the Clark Fork Route, it existed for only three years and was lightly used. The packers simply preferred outfitting from Walla Walla, where they could enjoy civilian comforts not found in the gold fields. As Alexander Campbell McGregor notes, “Walla Walla simply had too many . . . advantages for other nearby rivals to compete.” In an effort to attract more business to the Clark Fork Route, the OSN offered preferential rates for the White Bluffs route, which had no affect other than to outrage Walla Walla citizens. The Statesman, a Walla Walla newspaper that frequently reported on the arrival and departure of pack trains, summed up local sentiment in an 1866 editorial: “The Pend Orielle route is the greatest humbug of all the bilks of which this country is so prolific, and which its father, the Oregon Steam Navigation Company, has begotten for purposes vile as the prostitution of its own offspring.” Had the Clark Fork Route succeeded, Walla Walla may never have enjoyed its prosperity and status. However, the Clark Fork Route failed, not because of Walla Walla’s prominence alone, but because of the success of Missouri River navigation and the construction of the first transcontinental railway in 1869.
The OSN counted on the many difficulties of Missouri River navigation for the success of the Clark Fork Route, assuming traffic on the Missouri would remain sporadic. While such an assumption seemed logical at the time, they could not have been more mistaken. Steamboat landings at Fort Benton increased from fewer than five per year from 1860-1865, to thirty-one in 1866. As a result, freight tonnage unloaded at Fort Benton in 1866 was more than double the cumulative total of the previous five years. This success severely limited the OSN’s attempts to monopolize the Montana trade.
While the steamboats of St. Louis and Portland firms were churning up their respective water courses, the Union Pacific Railroad was building westward to a meeting with the Central Pacific at Promontory, Utah. Construction was completed in 1869, and on May 10, the gold spike was driven, connecting the East and West coasts by rail. The affect of the first transcontinental railroad was felt almost immediately by the steamboat companies; the railroad provided a third alternative for reaching the gold fields. With the completion of the transcontinental railroad and successful competition from the Missouri River steamboats, the OSN abandoned their operations on the Clark Fork Route in 1869. However, 1869 was a difficult year on the Missouri River too; the water level reached the lowest point of the decade. As a result, only eighteen steamboats succeeded in reaching Fort Benton, and only after extreme difficulty. Six steamboats were forced to turn back, unable to make it past Dauphin’s Rapids. Shipments from the east were now transferred to Union Pacific trains and unloaded at Corrine, Utah, and shipped northward by wagon. Although steamboats continued to call on Fort Benton, the glory days of Missouri River steamboating were over.
The Clark Fork Route never really stood a chance of dominating the Montana gold trade, but it illustrates the desire for a more efficient transportation system. By 1866
Walla Walla was firmly established as the largest city in the northern West, and its power enabled it to keep the Montana traffic routed through the Mullan Road. Despite the poor condition of the Mullan Road, pack trains made heavy use of the route from Walla Walla over the Bitterroot Mountains to Montana. Although Captain John Mullan originally thought the Clark Fork Route would be too difficult for constructing a wagon road, upon finishing the Mullan Road over the Bitterroot Mountains he acknowledged the superiority of the Clark Fork Route. In his 1863 report to Congress, he wrote, “I candidly believe the government would eventually find it to its advantage to open a line through the mountains via the Clark’s Fork, to the Hell’s Gate, and thence use my road to Fort Benton.” However, no construction was undertaken.
The Missouri River steamboats proved remarkably adept at avoiding and overcoming the numerous hindrances to navigation and further contributed to the demise of the Clark Fork Route. During the middle and late 1860s, the steamboat profits on the Missouri River were so great that the boats paid for themselves twice over in just one trip. The exorbitant freight charges were short-lived as the completion of the transcontinental railroad in 1869 created a reorientation of interior freighting. Rather than haul cargo to the landing at Fort Benton, teamsters drove to the railway connections for year round service. The railroad did not have to contend with low water, or costly and time consuming portages. All these factors combined to force the OSN to abandon the Clark Fork Route. Although the Mary Moody continued to steam across Pend Oreille Lake for several more years, the Clark Fork Route was destined to be a short-lived experiment in frontier transportation development.
Bibliography
McGregor, Alexander Campbell, The Economic Impact of the Mullan Road on Walla Walla, 1860-1883, Masters Thesis, Whitman College, 1971.
McGregor’s thesis is the most complete single source I have found on the Mullan Road. The focus is on the economic development and impact of the road on the Walla Walla Country; however, the final two chapters detail later uses of the road, which include “The Mullan Road and Livestock Drives: 1862-1883” and “The Mullan Road Becomes an Eastern Washington Thoroughfare: 1872-1883.” The bibliography to this thesis is extremely useful for further research.
Mullan, Captain John, U.S.A., Report on the Construction of a Military Road from Fort Walla-Walla to Fort Benton, Fairfield, Washington: Ye Galleon Press, 1998.
This is the report issued by Captain Mullan upon his return to Washington D.C. from building the road. While the report of the road construction is packed with information, many of the appended documents provide a wealth of additional detail regarding numerous observations of the region the Mullan Road passes through.
Oviatt, Alton B., “Steamboat Traffic on the Upper Missouri River, 1859-1869,” Pacific Northwest Quarterly, Vol.40, No.2 (April 1949), 93-105.
This is an in-depth study of steamboats on the Missouri River during the heyday of the river traffic. Oviatt accounts for the difficulties in navigation, as well as the extremely high profits made by steamboat contracts. It provides an important look at the rapid increase and sharp decline of the Missouri River as the primary outlet for the Montana gold fields.
Schwantes, Carlos, A., Long Day’s Journey: The Steamboat & Stagecoach Era in the Northern West, Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1999.
Schwantes provides a sweeping survey of transportation in the pre-railroad northern West. Although the text is very readable, it does not contribute new information to transportation studies. The strength of this book is its lavish illustrations, obtained from numerous collections which depict the dangers and excitement of frontier development.
Throckmorton, Arthur L., Oregon Argonauts: Merchant Adventurers on the Western Frontier, Portland: Oregon Historical Society, 1961.
The frontier merchants could make huge profits supplying remote towns and mines with supplies, but they also overcame incredible difficulties to obtain their products for sale. This is an account of how the merchants contributed to the development of the Northwest. For this paper, chapter 12, entitled “Gold from Idaho and Montana” was particularly helpful.